Safe Sex Stories: After the Reading

On the first Tuesday in April, the independent bookstore on Harbord hosted a reading called Small Fires, which meant folding chairs in the poetry aisle, warm white string lights that stayed up year-round, and a crowd of people carrying tote bags with the solemnity of saints handling relics.

Mara almost didn’t go.

She had spent the day translating other people’s urgency into presentable language, which was most of what public relations work turned out to be. At thirty-two, she had become unreasonably skilled at taking a panicked email from a client and turning it into a calm statement with bullet points and a quote from somebody whose title sounded expensive. By six-thirty, her eyes ached, her jaw ached, and the idea of going straight home to eat cereal over the sink had an exhausted holiness to it.

But her friend Tegan had texted at noon: You need to leave your apartment and stand near books. It’s medicinal.

Tegan was often right in exactly the way Mara found irritating until later. So at seven-forty-five she found herself shrugging out of a denim jacket still cold from the evening air and slipping into the back of the bookstore, where the last reader was already at the mic saying something earnest about grief and tomatoes.

The room smelled like paper, wool, and wet pavement carried in on people’s cuffs. A woman near the front laughed with her whole face, sudden and bright, at one perfectly timed line. Mara noticed her because of the laugh first, and then because the woman turned slightly in her chair and Mara could see the smooth arc of a shaved side under dark curls, the gold ring in one nostril, the loose cream shirt tucked into charcoal trousers. She looked composed without looking effortful, like somebody who had decided once, long ago, what mattered and stopped apologizing for it.

After the reading, the crowd redistributed itself into the familiar post-event choreography of browsing, lingering, pretending to consider hardcovers while actually trying to extend a mood. Mara drifted toward a display of essay collections she could not afford and picked one up because it gave her hands something to do.

“That one will make you underline so much you’ll have to declare bankruptcy in pencil,” a voice said beside her.

Mara looked up. It was the woman from the folding chairs. Up close, she had long lashes and a scar, pale and thin, along the inside of one wrist.

“That’s a compelling anti-blurb,” Mara said.

The woman smiled. “I’m serious. My copy looks like it survived a theological dispute.”

“Maybe that’s what I’m in the market for.”

“A dispute?”

“A survivable one.”

That made the woman laugh again, softly this time. “Fair.” She touched the spine of the book in Mara’s hands. “It’s good, though.”

“Noted.” Mara hesitated, then offered, “I’m Mara.”

“Nico.”

They shook hands with the slight awkwardness of strangers who had already established a tiny intimacy through banter and now had to acknowledge they were, in fact, still strangers. Nico’s hand was warm, dry, deliberate. Mara felt the contact in her stomach more than her palm.

“Do you know the readers?” Mara asked.

“One of them. My old roommate from grad school. I came to support her and accidentally became emotionally invested in everyone’s metaphors.” Nico tilted her head. “You?”

“My friend bullied me into attending for my own good.”

“A noble service.”

“Apparently I looked too much like somebody whose browser history was becoming a cry for help.”

Nico’s mouth quirked. “Specific.”

“She’s a specific person.”

They wandered together without deciding to. The bookstore was closing in twenty minutes, but staff had that benevolent local-business patience that encouraged dawdling as long as you looked literary about it. Mara learned that Nico was thirty-five, taught costume design part-time at a college downtown, and did freelance wardrobe work for theatre productions when schedules aligned and budgets pretended to exist. Mara admitted she worked in PR for arts organizations and startups, which Nico said sounded like “emotional triage with a style guide.”

“That’s the best description of my job I’ve ever heard,” Mara said.

“I’m available for ghostwriting and mild exorcisms.”

At the register, Mara bought the essay collection and a chapbook she hadn’t intended to buy. Nico picked up a slim novel and a packet of cardamom gum from the counter display. Outside, Toronto had settled into that early-spring night that felt temporarily merciful: cool, damp, no longer actively trying to punish exposed skin.

People streamed past along the sidewalk in pairs and loose groups. A restaurant down the block had its windows fogged from within. Someone across the street was laughing too loudly into a phone.

“Do you have anywhere to be?” Nico asked.

Mara considered lying for one useless second out of habit. Then she didn’t. “No.”

“There’s a late café on Bloor that makes very good tea and terrible playlists.”

“That sounds ideal.”

The café had green tile, bentwood chairs, and the kind of low amber lighting designed to make everyone look as if they had once been kissed in Paris. They found a small table by the window. Nico ordered mint tea. Mara got black tea and a square of olive oil cake dense enough to count as emotional equipment.

The conversation deepened with unusual ease. Not because they had everything in common; they didn’t. Nico was measured where Mara tended toward velocity, and had the sort of practical calm Mara associated with people who knew how to hem their own clothes and keep basil alive. But they were fluent in the same register of attention. They liked details. They liked stories about work that revealed character more than accomplishment. They liked admitting what they were actually trying, and occasionally failing, to build with their lives.

“I got out of a long relationship in November,” Mara said at one point, tracing the rim of her cup with one finger. “Nothing dramatic. No betrayal, no broken dishes. We just became very efficient roommates with good politics.”

Nico nodded with her whole attention. “That can be harder to leave than chaos.”

“Exactly.” Mara exhaled. “There was nothing to point to and say, this is the obvious end. Just… a growing absence.”

“Absence has excellent endurance,” Nico said. “It can sit in a room forever and still act surprised when someone names it.”

Mara looked at her over the steam. “You do costume design and just accidentally say things like that?”

“Occupational hazard. Too much Chekhov in my twenties.”

Mara grinned. “And you?”

Nico shrugged one shoulder. “Single. Dating occasionally. Mostly women, sometimes nonbinary people, every so often a person who rearranges my taxonomies by existing.” She held Mara’s gaze. “I like clarity more than mystery at this age.”

It was not flirtation with a neon sign around it. It was better. It was simple and adult and left room for return.

“Same,” Mara said, and felt the air between them alter by a degree or two.

By the time the café staff began stacking stools at the far end of the room, they had covered exes, theatre superstitions, favourite city corners, and the strange intimacy of borrowing books. Outside, the sidewalks shone from a brief rain neither of them had noticed starting.

“I’m around the corner,” Nico said, pulling on a dark coat. “Would you want to keep talking at my place?” She paused just long enough to make refusal easy if Mara wanted it. “No pressure. I also accept the honorable conclusion of ‘this was lovely, goodnight.’”

Mara felt a heat move through her, low and immediate, but not reckless. Nico had somehow made the invitation feel spacious rather than loaded, which made wanting to say yes much easier.

“I’d like that,” she said.

Nico lived in an old low-rise above a bakery that had already gone dark for the night. On the stairs, the air smelled faintly of yeast and soap. Her apartment was all softened corners: framed costume sketches, a blue couch with a blanket thrown over one arm, a rail of clothes in the living room that looked too beautiful to hide in a closet, and plants positioned like they had unionized for the good light.

“Water?” Nico asked.

“Please.”

Nico handed her a glass from the kitchen and leaned against the counter, not crowding her. Mara drank, aware of her own pulse now, of the day falling away from her body in layers.

“Can I kiss you?” Nico asked.

The directness of it made Mara smile before she answered. “Yes.”

The kiss began gently, almost curious, and then became something warmer and more certain. Nico’s palm rested at the side of Mara’s neck, thumb just below her ear. Mara slid a hand under the lapel of Nico’s coat and felt the heat of her through the shirt beneath. The room seemed to narrow to breath, cloth, the soft sound of Nico setting her own water glass down on the counter without looking.

They kissed again, slower, then with more hunger. Mara made a small sound she had not intended to make. Nico answered with one of her own, lower, and Mara felt it like an invitation opening.

“Still good?” Nico murmured.

“Very.” Mara touched the gold ring in Nico’s nose, then the line of her jaw. “You?”

“Very.”

Nico smiled against her mouth and kissed her once more, then let her breathe. That too was part of the seduction, Mara realized—the unhurriedness. Nico never seemed to grab at the moment. She shaped it.

In the bedroom, a lamp on the dresser cast everything in a warm apricot glow. There was a quilt the color of dark plums, a bookshelf with scripts and novels shoved together, and a small dish on the nightstand holding rings, hair ties, and one stray earring shaped like a tiny silver hand.

Nico sat on the edge of the bed and drew Mara between her knees with a hand at her waist.

“I want to keep going,” she said, looking up at her. “But I like checking in before clothes start making unreasonable demands. What are you into? What should I know?”

Mara laughed, a little breathless. “That is a wildly hot sentence.”

“Good. I hoped so.”

Mara tucked a strand of hair behind one ear and answered honestly, because the room seemed built for honesty. “I like being asked. I like slowness until I don’t. I like praise if it feels real. I don’t like assumptions. I’ve got a mild thing for being pinned down if there’s plenty of communication attached.”

Nico nodded once, absorbing rather than reacting. “Noted. I like responsiveness. I like taking my time. I like feeling like we’re making something together, not performing something we inherited from the internet.”

That made Mara laugh outright. “God, yes.”

“Any hard no’s?”

“Nothing with pain tonight.” Mara considered. “And if we use toys, I want barriers.”

Nico’s expression softened into something appreciative and bright. “Excellent. Same page.”

They undressed in stages, punctuated by kisses and small incidents of human comedy: Mara getting briefly trapped in her own sweater, Nico steadying her when she nearly toppled trying to toe off one boot while standing. By the time they reached the bed, they were both smiling too much to pretend this was some polished cinematic event, which only made the intimacy feel more real.

Nico kissed with meticulous generosity. Her mouth at Mara’s throat, her hand warm over Mara’s hip, the drag of fingertips along her ribs as if learning a script by touch. Mara felt herself becoming less self-conscious by the minute, as if Nico’s attention made shame too boring to maintain.

When Nico pressed her gently back onto the quilt and held one of her wrists above her head for half a second—just enough to ask the question with pressure instead of words—Mara looked at her and said, “Yes. That.”

Nico’s eyes darkened, pleased. “Good.”

She kept it exactly there: controlled, communicative, unmistakably consensual. Her hand loosened whenever Mara shifted. Her mouth kept returning, as if every intensification deserved tenderness built around it. Mara had dated enough people to know how rare that combination was, hunger without entitlement.

At a natural pause, Nico reached toward the nightstand drawer.

“I have lube, gloves, condoms, and a couple of toys,” she said. “Want to tell me what sounds good?”

Mara, already flushed and open and wanting, felt another wave of heat at the matter-of-factness. It didn’t break the mood. It sharpened it. Preparation as seduction. Logistics as trust.

“Condoms if we use a toy,” Mara said. “And lube. Maybe your hand first.”

“Absolutely.”

Nico opened the drawer. Inside was a tidy, practical arrangement that somehow looked more intimate than decorative ever could: water-based lube, nitrile gloves, a few foil packets, a slim vibrator, everything easy to reach without fuss. Mara found it deeply attractive that someone had decided in advance that pleasure deserved infrastructure.

Nico started with her hand, slick with lube, checking in with a glance each time Mara’s breathing changed. “Like this?” she asked. “More?” “Stay here?” Each question felt less like caution and more like attention refined to a point. Mara answered without self-editing because Nico had made honesty feel rewarded.

Later, when the toy became part of it, Nico held up the condom packet first, letting Mara see. “Still good?”

“Yes.”

Nico tore it open and rolled the condom smoothly over the toy, then added more lube with patient hands. The gesture was competent and unembarrassed, and because it was competent and unembarrassed, it was intensely erotic. Mara reached down and touched Nico’s wrist. “That’s very hot.”

Nico smiled, not stopping. “I think so too.”

It struck Mara, even then, that this was the opposite of every stale narrative that treated safer sex like an interruption. Nothing had paused. The whole encounter was a braid of wanting and paying attention, desire and care reinforcing rather than competing with each other.

Nico stayed close, kissing Mara between questions, keeping one hand anchored at her thigh whenever she asked for more with the other. When Mara needed slower, Nico slowed. When Mara wanted firmer pressure, Nico gave it. When Mara said, voice breaking a little, “Don’t stop,” Nico answered with a low sound that traveled through Mara like weather.

After, Nico disposed of the condom neatly in a lined bin by the nightstand and returned with a warm washcloth. Mara accepted it with a laugh that almost tipped into something more emotional.

“What?” Nico asked gently, sitting beside her.

“Nothing,” Mara said, then corrected herself because the night had not been built for evasions. “Not nothing. Just… this level of competence is a little overwhelming.”

Nico brushed her knuckles over Mara’s shoulder. “In a bad way?”

“God, no.” Mara turned to look at her. “In a way where I may have to revise my standards upward forever.”

Nico’s laugh was soft and pleased. “That seems healthy.”

They drank water in bed while the radiator hissed faintly below the window. Nico pulled on a T-shirt and offered Mara one too, a faded black thing from some long-ago theatre festival. In the kitchen, she cut two oranges and found crackers and a wedge of cheese, assembling a midnight plate with the seriousness of a person setting props for a scene she respected.

“This is absurdly civilized,” Mara said, perched on a stool in borrowed cotton.

“I reject the idea that aftercare should lack snacks.”

“A philosopher.”

“A Taurus.”

Mara laughed so hard she had to set down her orange slice.

They ate at the counter, hips nearly touching. Outside, the city had gone quieter, though not silent. Somewhere below, a late streetcar complained around a corner.

“Can I ask something that is maybe too practical for the glow we’re currently inhabiting?” Mara said.

Nico considered. “I love practical questions in a glow.”

“Do you always keep… all this around?” Mara gestured loosely, encompassing the drawer, the washcloth, the water, the calm.

Nico leaned an elbow on the counter. “Pretty much. Different people need different things, and I’d rather be prepared than improvise badly. I keep good lube, barriers, a latex-free option, a couple of sizes of condoms for toys or whatever the evening asks for.” She smiled. “Plus it saves having to interrupt the mood with a panicked pharmacy run.”

“That,” Mara said, “is one of the sexiest monologues I’ve ever heard.”

“Then let me continue my TED Talk.” Nico got up and, with zero self-consciousness, opened the nearby drawer so Mara could see the small neatly stocked selection. Among the boxes was one Mara recognized from a friend’s enthusiastic recommendation and a late-night rabbit hole of reviews: SKYN Elite Condoms. Beside it was another familiar staple, slim and low-drama in its packaging: LifeStyles SKYN Selection Non-Latex Condoms.

“Curated,” Mara said.

“Exactly. A capsule collection.”

“For safety.”

“For possibilities,” Nico corrected, though she was smiling when she said it.

They carried their snacks back to bed and sat cross-legged against the headboard, talking in the softened post-midnight register that bypassed small talk entirely. Mara told Nico about growing up in Mississauga with parents who loved her fiercely but communicated mostly through concern. Nico told Mara about an aunt in Hamilton who had taught her to sew and once said, while fitting a hem, that half of adulthood was keeping supplies for the version of life you hoped to have.

“That applies to more than thread,” Mara said.

Nico glanced at her. “Exactly.”

There was something startlingly intimate about the ease of it, this movement from explicit touch to conversation without embarrassment or collapse. Mara had known nights that were physically charged and emotionally vacant, and nights that were emotionally promising but physically uncertain. This felt rarer: grounded in both body and personhood at once.

At one point Nico reached to tuck Mara’s feet under the quilt because they had gone cold. The tenderness of the small gesture landed almost harder than anything else had.

“You’re very good at making things feel easy,” Mara said quietly.

Nico looked down at her hands, then back up. “That’s kind of you. I think I just like being intentional. Especially now. I wasted a lot of my twenties pretending that confusion was romantic.”

Mara let that sit between them for a moment. “I used to think asking clearly for what you wanted would ruin it.”

“And now?”

Mara met her eyes. “Now I think it might be the thing that makes it possible.”

Nico leaned in and kissed her, slow and sweet, nothing to prove in it. Mara kissed her back with the serene certainty of someone who had accidentally found exactly the right room.

Eventually, drowsiness overtook even curiosity. Nico turned off the lamp, and the room settled into blue-dark shapes: the outline of the dresser, the pale rectangle of the window, the suggestion of clothes draped over the chair. Mara lay on her side facing Nico, who was close enough that the warmth of her traveled easily through the quilt.

In the dark, Mara thought about how much nonsense people were taught to tolerate around intimacy: silence mistaken for sophistication, care mistaken for awkwardness, preparedness mistaken for pessimism. Tonight had felt like a correction to all of it. Desire had not become smaller because it was discussed. It had become trustworthy. Safety had not arrived as an outside rule imposed on pleasure. It had arrived as part of pleasure’s architecture.

She thought, too, of the bookstore chairs and the string lights and that first laugh she’d heard before she knew whose it was. How strange and ordinary it was that a whole evening could tilt on something so small.

“You awake?” Nico murmured.

“Barely.”

“Good,” Nico said sleepily. “Then I can say this without having to perform being cool about it.”

Mara smiled into the pillow. “Go on.”

“I’m very glad you came for tea.”

Mara opened her eyes in the dark. “I’m very glad you insulted my book selection.”

Nico laughed once, quietly enough that it felt private even in an empty room. “Would you maybe want to have dinner this weekend? In a less accidental context.”

Mara’s answer came without hesitation. “Yes.”

“Okay,” Nico said, and there was a smile in the word. “Good.”

They slept then, not tangled into some impossible knot but comfortably adjacent, the way adults with real joints and real jobs often do. In the morning there would be phones, transit alerts, deadlines, receipts in coat pockets, the ordinary bureaucracy of being alive. But for that hour there was only rain beginning again against the window and the warm knowledge of a body nearby that had asked, listened, prepared, and answered in kind.

Mara let herself drift at last with the odd, steady happiness of feeling both desired and safe, as if the two had always belonged together and she had only just found the proof.

---

Fiction disclaimer: This story is a work of fiction. All characters are adults. Any resemblance to real people or actual events is purely coincidental.